The High Fat Meal Study
A high fat meal was pinned against a low fat meal in looking at short term effects on FMD . The high fat meal, with 45 grams of fat, led to a statistically significant decrease of FMD for two to four after the meal (recall that "statistically significant" just means that the changes did not occur due to chance). The fat-free meal essentially did not change FMD at all. You can see the results below in the chart.
In their conclusion, the authors stated that saturated fat is an independent predictor of cardiovascular disease risk. I mean, it seems pretty straight forward: this study clearly shows that fat is bad for your arteries. Why don't we just consider that conclusion a fact so you can get back to watching TV and I can get ready for my flight to New York tomorrow?
Unfortunately, it's not so straight forward. Lets look at the details. Here are the meals consumed by the groups:
High fat meal: Egg McMuffin®, Sausage McMuffin®, 2 hash brown patties, and an unspecified beverage.
Fat-free meal: Frosted Flakes®, skimmed milk, and orange juice.
Outside of the fat content for both groups and the caloric intake for the high fat group, the authors did not include any nutritional facts. I used McDonald's Meal Builder to figure out the nutritional facts for the high fat meal. Here are some of the key facts:
- 900 calories
- 440 calories from fat
- 45 grams of fat, including 16 grams of saturated fat
- 75 grams of carbs
- 40 grams of protein
- Two milligrams of vitamin C (4% of daily value)
The fat-free meal was said to have zero grams of fat and nothing else can be determined as the quantities of each food and drink were unlisted.
It's impossible to conclude from this study that saturated fat alone leads to a short-term digression of FMD: most of the fat calories are from unsaturated fat, and fat makes up less than half of the calories - there are several other possible causes!
Lets start with the ingredients for a McDonald's hash brown: corn oil, hydrogenated soybean oil, dextrose, corn flour, and it's prepared by cooking in corn oil, hydrogenated soybean oil, and canola oil. Those oils are loaded with omega-6 fatty acids, one is hydrogenated, and they all have very low thresholds for heat (meaning they are chemically altered for the worse when heat is applied). Translation: this is a recipe for cardiovascular disaster. The buns on the breakfast sandwiches include similar oils and high fructose corn syrup, and the eggs are made with hydrogenated soybean oil as well. The entire high fat meal is a chemical disaster and bears little resemblance to a piece of organic meat cooked at home in butter or coconut oil at a low temperature.
The lack of change in the fat-free meal provides another reason for the difference in FMD changes: vitamin C content. The fat-free group ate frosted flakes along with skim milk and orange juice (a great meal...if you are five years old) - basically all simple carbohydrates. Even though a major change didn't occur, I believe that the carbohydrate/sugar content did negatively affect FMD. Vitamin C has demonstrated a strong, positive effect on FMD in previous research , but I believe the vitamin C in this case just attenuated for the damage of the sugar. I will discuss sugar in the next (and last) installment of the FMD series. As for now, knowing that vitamin C helps FMD, the fat-free group would have benefited significantly more from drinking a modest eight-ounce glass of orange juice (about 163% of the daily recommended amount, as opposed to the 4% consumed in the high fat group).
Here's what I think you should take from the studies presented above:
- If you eat meals high in vegetable oils (think: omega-6 fatty acids), especially those with hydrogenated oils, you are likely going to decrease artery function in the short term (continued short term decreases lead to long term digression). Both vegetable oils and hydrogenated oils of all types are largely found in processed foods. If it doesn't have an ingredient label, you are safe.
- Vitamin C improves arterial function. The fact that the high sugar, fat-free meal decreased slightly in the presence of vitamin C indicates to me that vitamin C can attenuate for the damage of some poor eating.
- Don't eat fast food. Even the typically-healthy foods, like eggs that are offered at these restaurants are dense with unhealthy chemicals. You should not trust anything on the menu, even if the nutritional facts seem harmless.
In the next and final FMD post, I'm going to discuss the effects of simple carbohydrates on your arteries and heart health. It may change what you view as a "heart-healthy meal."